Cardpool Review: Pretty Amazing for Unloading Gift Cards Fast

gift cards

It’s that time of the year again, when we scramble to make sure any and all calendar-year travel credits are exhausted. For those who still have unused credits, they might be looking at gift cards to get the job done.

As most of you know, gift cards typically trigger travel credits offered by credit card issuers, so for those who aren’t traveling, or have no plans to, buying an airline gift card can fill in the blanks.

This doesn’t always work by the way, and varies by card, so it’s important to know what works and what doesn’t before you go and spend $100 or more, only to find out the credit didn’t actually fire!

For example, the Bank of America Premium Rewards travel credit seems to be especially picky.

My Gift Card Journey with Cardpool

how paid

  • I bought a gift card to trigger a travel credit
  • Since I had no immediate travel plans and didn’t want it to go to waste
  • Instead of using the gift card in the future
  • I simply sold it to Cardpool for cash and received a check in about a week

Once you buy, you can either hold onto the gift card and use it eventually, or unload it, either for cash or to a friend or family member.

Back when I had Chase Sapphire Reserve (before canceling after a year), I bought some Southwest gift cards to trigger the credit. I actually used those because I travel with them fairly often.

But I didn’t need more, and when it came time to collect my credits for my Schwab Amex Platinum, I decided to go with American Airlines because they seem to be in decent demand relative to other airlines.

At first, I thought about selling on Raise, but then I discovered a huge downside. They won’t let you list gift cards until 45 days have passed since they were issued. Hmm…yeah, way too impatient for that.

So I moved on, even checking out Reddit’s marketplace, which seemed a bit too involved and potentially risky if I got caught up with a bad apple. So I kept digging.

I made my way over to GiftCardZen and while they were ready to buy my gift card, they offered some absurd $20 or something for my $100 AA card. Hard pass.

Cardpool Seems Pretty Straightforward


  • Instead of dealing with selling it to someone
  • And going through all that stress, work, and uncertainty
  • I decided to just sell it to Cardpool for a flat no-nonsense rate
  • And since it didn’t explicitly cost me anything, I was happy to take ~86% value

Then I found Cardpool, which seemed really streamlined. I had heard of the company but never used it. I clicked on sell gift cards and instantly saw a really fair offer, at least in my eyes.

They were offering over $80, which sure, is 20% off, but it’s also 80% for doing a little more than nothing. I didn’t have to list the card and wait to have someone buy it, or work to find a seller on my own.

I could instantly offload it to them and get paid in a few days. They also have an option to redeem for an Amazon gift card, which results in 6% more. That pushed the total to nearly $87, which is better than I would have expected just about anywhere.

They also give you the option to list the card yourself for any amount up to a certain limit, which seemed to be around $96 in my particular case.

If you go that route, you’ll get paid once someone buys your card from their marketplace. I suppose I could try that too, I’m just really impatient. And when it’s only ~$5 or so, it’s hard to bother.

Could I Do Better Than Cardpool? And One Warning…

  • It’s certainly possible to sell your gift cards for more money
  • But you have to factor in the work involved (and the risk)
  • The one catch with Cardpool that I saw in the terms and conditions
  • Is that they can charge your credit card if for some reason your gift card is used by accident

In any case, the instant sale of gift cards for cash or Amazon gift cards is amazingly easy and borderline delightful. I value convenience and no-nonsense above most things these days, and that’s what I got with Cardpool.

I’m sure it’s possible to do better elsewhere, and maybe it’s not that hard to actually sell on their marketplace. I have no idea, cards might sell in days or even hours. I’ll have to test that out at some point.

But in the meantime, I’m happy to get most of the value back in a matter of days with little more effort than filling out a short form, especially since I have multiple cards that earn travel credits.

There is one caveat: once you sell to Cardpool, they note that because the card has been sold, it’s your responsibility to ensure it isn’t used by accident. If it is, they can charge your credit card, which is why they ask you to enter a credit card when selling a card.

Don’t freak out about it, just make sure the gift card isn’t inadvertently used.

This is pretty easy with an e-gift card, though you may want to remind yourself not to use it if you’re in possession of a bunch of gift cards. I don’t think it’ll be an issue, but it’s a possibility.

Other than that, if you value convenience over highest possible value, this service from Cardpool seems pretty incredible. And the value is still really darn good in my opinion.

By Colin Robertson

Colin created this blog after spending several years in a job that required him to scour credit reports on a daily basis. His goal is to help individuals better understand their credit and get the most out of credit cards.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *